In-store showcase

Magic: The Gathering Singles.

From original dual lands and Reserved List rares to current Standard staples and Commander build-arounds, the case is loaded with playable and collectible Magic singles at current market rates. Browse in-store, call ahead with a want list, or DM on social. Sold at the counter only — no online checkout.

PKM MTG LRC YGO

201 listings · page 3 of 9

Seifer Almasy
MTG
Seifer Almasy
Final Fantasy NM rare
Low Stock $3.60
Molten-Core Maestro
MTG
Molten-Core Maestro
Secrets of Strixhaven NM rare
Low Stock $3.50
Relic Retriever
MTG
Relic Retriever
Secrets of Strixhaven Commander NM rare
Low Stock $3.40
Twilight Diviner
MTG
Twilight Diviner
Lorwyn Eclipsed Promos NM rare
Low Stock $3.40
Waterbender's Restoration
MTG
Waterbender's Restoration
Avatar: The Last Airbender Eternal NM rare
Low Stock $3.30
Black Cat, Cunning Thief
MTG
Black Cat, Cunning Thief
Marvel's Spider-Man NM rare
Low Stock $3.20
Duty Beyond Death
MTG
Duty Beyond Death
Tarkir: Dragonstorm NM uncommon
Low Stock $3.20
Earthbender Ascension
MTG
Earthbender Ascension
Avatar: The Last Airbender NM rare
Low Stock $3.10
Summon: G.F. Cerberus
MTG
Summon: G.F. Cerberus
Final Fantasy Promos NM rare
Low Stock $3.00
Tectonic Split
MTG
Tectonic Split
Avatar: The Last Airbender Eternal NM rare
Low Stock $3.00
Withering Curse
MTG
Withering Curse
Secrets of Strixhaven NM mythic
Low Stock $3.00
The Dawning Archaic
MTG
The Dawning Archaic
Secrets of Strixhaven NM mythic
Low Stock $2.90
Scorched Geyser
MTG
Scorched Geyser
Secrets of Strixhaven Commander NM rare
Low Stock $2.80
Donatello, Mutant Mechanic
MTG
Donatello, Mutant Mechanic
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles NM mythic
Low Stock $2.60
Iron Spider, Stark Upgrade
MTG
Iron Spider, Stark Upgrade
Through the Omenpaths NM rare
Low Stock $2.60
Twilight Diviner
MTG
Twilight Diviner
Lorwyn Eclipsed NM rare
Low Stock $2.60
Subterranean Tremors
MTG
Subterranean Tremors
Secrets of Strixhaven Mystical Archive NM mythic
Low Stock $2.50
United Front
MTG
United Front
Avatar: The Last Airbender NM mythic
Low Stock $2.50
Mirrormind Crown
MTG
Mirrormind Crown
Lorwyn Eclipsed Promos NM rare
Low Stock $2.30
The Cloning of Shredder
MTG
The Cloning of Shredder
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles NM mythic
Low Stock $2.30
The Endstone
MTG
The Endstone
Edge of Eternities NM mythic
Low Stock $2.30
Molten-Core Maestro
MTG
Molten-Core Maestro
Secrets of Strixhaven NM rare
Low Stock $2.20
The Unagi of Kyoshi Island
MTG
The Unagi of Kyoshi Island
Avatar: The Last Airbender NM rare
Low Stock $2.20
Changing Loyalty
MTG
Changing Loyalty
Secrets of Strixhaven Commander NM rare
Low Stock $2.10

Prices updated daily and subject to change. Ask staff to verify availability. Singles are sold in-store only - no online checkout.

How to Buy Singles

All singles sold in-person at the counter

Browse In-Store

Walk in during store hours and browse the showcase directly. Singles are organized by game and set, making it easy to find what you're after.

Ask Staff

Looking for something specific? Staff can pull cards from the back on request. Searches typically take about five minutes. Call ahead to save time if you have a long want list.

Grading & Slabs

We accept grading submissions in-store and carry graded slabs (PSA, BGS, CGC) in the showcase from $40. Interested in getting your cards graded? Ask staff about current rates and turnaround time.

What We Stock

Era and format coverage by game

MTG

Magic: The Gathering

Our primary focus — the case runs deep across every era, with genuine strength in Commander staples, format-defining cards, and the Reserved List.

  • Old School Beta / Unlimited / Revised — original dual lands and early staples when in stock
  • Reserved List Hand-selected Reserved List cards across the eras
  • Modern Format Fetch lands, shock lands, finishers, and Modern-legal sideboard staples
  • Commander Format staples + powerful build-around commanders across all colors
  • Standard & New Latest sets — playable singles, foils, full-art and Showcase variants
  • Foreign & Old Border Japanese, German, and other non-English printings of staples

Can't make it in?

Follow @madisonpegasusgames on Instagram for daily card showcases, pulls, price updates, and restock drops. DM us or call (608) 833-4263 to check availability on specific cards - especially vintage and high-value singles - before you make the trip.

Instagram Facebook